Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Explore Our Properties

Meet the Owner

Mallory Pinto
Banner Image

Mallory Pinto

Mallory Morton Pinto is the Broker and Owner of Keys Ocean Realty and the Owner of Keys Ocean Vacation Rentals, offering a unique full-circle approach to luxury coastal living in the Florida Keys.

Originally from the Northern, KY - Cincinnati, OH area, but raised in Marathon, Mallory has deep roots in the island community and a true passion for connecting people with the Keys lifestyle.
 
After years of representing buyers and sellers through Ocean Sotheby’s International Realty, Mallory launched Keys Ocean Realty to create a more personal, boutique, and locally inspired real estate experience. Her approach blends luxury marketing, strategic investment insight, and genuine hospitality — a combination shaped by her success running a thriving vacation rental company.
 
Mallory specializes in waterfront homes, investment properties, and high-end vacation rentals, delivering personalized guidance, strong market knowledge, and clear communication at every step. Her clients appreciate her professionalism, warmth, and thoughtful approach to both ownership and investment strategy.
 
Whether guiding a family to their forever home, advising an investor on rental potential, or welcoming guests to a Keys vacation, Mallory leads with integrity, local expertise, and a love for island living.
 
Keys Ocean Realty — Island Luxury Redefined.
 

Contact Details

Email address [email protected]
Primary phone (305) 209-8335
Address 1342 74th Street Ocean Marathon FL, 33050
License #BK3373799
See Why Clients Love Us

Testimonials

Read what our clients have to say about working with us.

"I wholeheartedly endorse Keys Ocean Realty - Marathon and their Broker Mallory Pinto. I have now worked with Mallory on numerous transactions and will continue working with her for all of my future real estate business. She also manages my portfolio of long term investment properties. When the time came to sell my 4 unit apartment building she worked diligently coordinating showings and inspections with the buyers and all 4 tenants. She also understood my desire to find a buyer that intended to keep the property long term housing for locals and I am proud to say a local business purchased this for workforce housing. When my mother passed away, Mallory called around and interviewed agents in Kentucky and helped me select another agent who expertly handled that transaction. If you are looking for a professional who understands our market, the best manager for investment properties and someone who stays connected to government rules and policies affecting real estate, look no further than Mallory Pinto. "
"I wholeheartedly endorse Keys Ocean Realty - Marathon and their Broker Mallory Pinto. I have now worked with Mallory on numerous transactions and will continue working with her for all of my future real estate business. She also manages my portfolio of long term investment properties. When the time came to sell my 4 unit apartment building she worked diligently coordinating showings and inspections with the buyers and all 4 tenants. She also understood my desire to find a buyer that intended to keep the property long term housing for locals and I am proud to say a local business purchased this for workforce housing. When my mother passed away, Mallory called around and interviewed agents in Kentucky and helped me select another agent who expertly handled that transaction. If you are looking for a professional who understands our market, the best manager for investment properties and someone who stays connected to government rules and policies affecting real estate, look no further than Mallory Pinto. "
Michelle L.
"Mallory was truly amazing. From start to finish, she made every step of the process smooth and easy, always taking the time to answer my questions — even after hours. Working with her felt like having a trusted friend on my side. Her market expertise, responsiveness, and professionalism made this the best and least stressful real estate experience I’ve ever had. Thank you, Mallory Pinto, for making everything so seamless!"
"Mallory was truly amazing. From start to finish, she made every step of the process smooth and easy, always taking the time to answer my questions — even after hours. Working with her felt like having a trusted friend on my side. Her market expertise, responsiveness, and professionalism made this the best and least stressful real estate experience I’ve ever had. Thank you, Mallory Pinto, for making everything so seamless!"
Beth F.
"Mallory is a great agent with awesome properties to fit all budgets. She was super friendly and knowledgeable. She understood our requirements and was an excellent negotiator. She was very responsive, and her knowledge of the area was A-plus. If you're looking for great expertise, look no further."
"Mallory is a great agent with awesome properties to fit all budgets. She was super friendly and knowledgeable. She understood our requirements and was an excellent negotiator. She was very responsive, and her knowledge of the area was A-plus. If you're looking for great expertise, look no further."
Roger C.
"Mallory was able to secure a buyer and keep the sale on track to close. Even after a category 4 Hurricane (IRMA) wiped out half the properties in the neighborhood. I have been a professional real estate investor/buyer/seller for over 30 years and Mallory is the best and most professional agent I have ever used."
"Mallory was able to secure a buyer and keep the sale on track to close. Even after a category 4 Hurricane (IRMA) wiped out half the properties in the neighborhood. I have been a professional real estate investor/buyer/seller for over 30 years and Mallory is the best and most professional agent I have ever used."
Seller

Notable Sales

Past Transactions

Discover waterfront, coastal-modern, and island hideaways curated for your lifestyle and goals. Navigate the market with trusted, investment-forward guidance and refined, boutique support.

  • 86 Pelican Road Sold

    $2,525,000

    86 Pelican Road, Marathon, FL 33050

    • 4 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 2,012 Sq.Ft.
  • 300 Duck Key Drive Unit: 12 Sold

    $385,000

    300 Duck Key Drive Unit: 12, Duck Key, FL 33050

    • 1 Bed
    • 1 Bath
    • 510 Sq.Ft.
  • 439 83Rd Street Ocean Street Ocean Sold

    $295,000

    439 83Rd Street Ocean Street Ocean, Marathon, FL 33050

    • 2 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,018 Sq.Ft.
  • 6099 Overseas Highway Unit: 71E Sold

    $130,000

    6099 Overseas Highway Unit: 71E, Marathon, FL 33050

    • 884 Sq.Ft.
View All

Find Your Dream Home Today

Search Homes

Follow Us On Instagram